Nathan Hochman Backs Challenge to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s Erasure of 548 Death Row Sentences

Posted

After condemning Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute nearly one-fourth of the nation’s death row sentences, Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman is backing those challenging the move.

Hochman announced his office’s support for the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation’s (CJLF) legal challenge against Newsom’s proposed blanket commutation of all 548 California death row sentences to life without the possibility of parole.

Hochman argues that approximately 382 of the cases involve individuals convicted of multiple felonies and require approval from a majority of the California Supreme Court before their sentences can be commuted.

More than 150 of the affected inmates were prosecuted in Los Angeles County.

Hochman criticized Newsom for making a blanket decision without consulting victims’ families or reviewing individual cases, arguing that the commutations undermine the decisions of juries and judges. He highlighted convicted serial killers Chester Turner, known as the “Southside Slayer” and convicted of 14 murders, and Michael Gargiulo, known as the “Hollywood Ripper” and convicted of two murders and the attempted murder of a third victim, as examples of violent offenders who would no longer face the death penalty.

“Each one of these cases leaves behind a victim’s family that went through agonizing proceedings for years or decades, reliving the tragedies that befell their loved ones over and over until they finally thought they had achieved some level of closure and finality — only to have it violently disrupted,” Hochman stated.

Newsom said he was in communication with some victims and their families when making the decision. In a letter explaining his decision, Newsom wrote that, when considering each individual case, he determined that every family considered their loss the “worst of the worst.”

“I have concluded that attempting to distinguish among crimes and offenders for clemency would inadvertently create two classes of murder victims – those whose perpetrators deserve the death penalty and then the rest,” Newsom said before announcing his decision to commute all death sentences to life without the possibility of parole.

Hochman questioned whether life without the possibility of parole guarantees inmates will remain incarcerated for life, citing the Menendez brothers’ eventual eligibility for parole following legislative changes.

The brothers were resentenced last year to 50 years to life after previously receiving life sentences without the possibility of parole for the 1989 murders of their parents, and have a parole suitability hearing scheduled for March 2027.

The Menendez brothers were 21 and 18 years old when they killed their parents. They have maintained that they endured years of sexual and emotional abuse at their parents’ hands.

Hochman pointed to California voters’ rejection of death penalty repeal measures in 2012 and 2016, arguing that the governor should not override voters’ decisions to keep capital punishment in place. The California Supreme Court is reviewing the constitutionality and scope of the proposed commutations, according to Hochman, who urged the court to reject mass clemency in favor of individualized review.

CJLF representatives and supporters gathered on the grounds of the California State Capitol on Thursday, challenging Newsom’s mass commutation of death sentences and vowing to fight the decision during a more than two-hour press conference.

Jane De Guzman, whose husband, Jonathan Matias De Guzman, was killed in the line of duty in 2016, spoke at the press conference. She described the day of his death as one that “changed our lives forever.” Jonathan was a father of two.

In 2022, Jesse Michael Gomez, 61, was convicted of first-degree murder in Jonathan’s killing and sentenced to death. De Guzman said it was “heartbreaking” to have to continue fighting for justice for her husband after spending years in court.

“I stand before you as a grieving wife and a mother to oppose reducing the killer from that sentence of life imprisonment,” De Guzman said. “Our family has already been sentenced to a life without him. Please remember the officer that lost his life, the wife who lost her husband and the children that lost their father.”

Benjamin Therriault, a former law enforcement officer and vice president of the Peace Officers Research Association, apologized to the victims’ families and condemned Newsom. He said the governor’s decision was not “mercy” but a “decree,” arguing that it went against the will of California voters.

In Santa Ana, victims’ families affected by Newsom’s proclamation also spoke out against the governor on Thursday. Steve Herr, father of U.S. Army Pfc. Samuel Eliezer “Sam” Herr, said his family has been hurting since the announcement. Sam was murdered by his neighbor, Daniel Wozniak, in 2010 at age 26.

Faye Jenkins, whose daughter, Quiana Jenkins-Pietrzak, and son-in-law were tortured and murdered in their home in 2008 during a racially motivated attack, also spoke out against the governor.

Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer announced his intention to ask the California Supreme Court to block the proposed commutations involving inmates from his jurisdiction. He said his office plans to file the request Monday.

“We’re going to make it unequivocally clear to the Supreme Court that they are being asked by the governor to overturn the decisions they made affirming these death cases,” Spitzer said.

A spokesperson for the Governor’s Office told Los Angeles‘ that they cannot comment on pending litigation, but maintained Newsom “acted within his constitutional authority” in commenting the death sentences, and said the decision must be approved by the State Supreme Court.

The post Nathan Hochman Backs Challenge to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s Erasure of 548 Death Row Sentences appeared first on LAmag.

News & City, News & Politics, Politics, Death Row, Governor Gavin Newsom, Los Angeles County, Los Angeles District Attorney, Menendez Brothers, Nathan Hochman, Todd Spitzer